If the Sheriffs die, script a way for an "Innocent" to pick up the dropped gun.
Give the Knife tool only to the Murderer and Revolvers only to Sheriffs. Roblox Script -- Murderer vs. Sheriffs | Kill A...
Sheriffs usually have a ranged weapon. Use a in ReplicatedStorage named ShootEvent to handle the bullet logic on the server. If the Sheriffs die, script a way for
Use a While true do loop to check if the Murderer is still alive or if all Sheriffs/Innocents are eliminated. If the Sheriffs die