Reviewers on The StoryGraph have described the book as "ridiculously heartwarming" and a solid choice for ending the year on a "sappy, happy" note. Common critiques include:
Some readers found the lack of direct communication between Elijah and Nathan frustrating at times. Mistletoe Wishes & Hookups by Kota Quinn
While the tone is generally lighthearted and hopeful, it explores "medium-paced" emotional development and the personal baggage both protagonists bring to the table. Critical Reception Reviewers on The StoryGraph have described the book